October 23, 2004
The Low Down on the Stem Cell Debate
Vice Presidential Nominee John Edwards said,
"If we do the work that we can
do in this country, the work that we will do when John Kerry is president,
Christopher Reeve are going to walk, get up out that wheelchair and walk
One person outraged by that comment was Dr. Charles
Krauthammer, a Pulitzer
Prize-winning columnist, who is confined to a wheelchair due to a spinal
he suffered as a medical student at age 22:
"In my 25 years in Washington, I have never seen a more
loathsome display of demagoguery. Hope is good. False hope is bad.
Deliberately, for personal gain, raising false hope in the catastrophically
afflicted is despicable...
"The inability of the human spinal cord to regenerate
is one of the great mysteries of
biology. The answer is not remotely around the corner. It could take a
generation to unravel. To imply, as Edward did, that it is imminent if only
you elect the right politicians is scandalous."
Last weekend Christopher Reeve, who starred in four
Superman movies, but was
paralyzed in a riding accident, died of a heart attack at age 52. He
was a gallant spokesman for embryonic stem cell research. He will be missed.
However, as Dr. David Prentice of the Family Research
Council, put it, Reeve "was an
effective champion for an ineffective product."
Since embryonic stem cells were isolated and cultured
in 1998, the promise of miracle
cures for devastating diseases have collided with reality. "After two
decades of research,
embryonic stem cells have not helped a single human being," asserts an ad
appearing in "USA Today" by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. "And
they come with a hefty price tag: they are only obtained by destroying a
living human embryo.
"Meanwhile, adult stem cells have helped thousands of
people including patients with
Parkinson's disease, spinal cord injury, sickle-cell anemia, heart
damage...And these stem cells are readily available, found in bone marrow,
umbilical cord blood, skin, fat..."
For example, Dr. Richard Burt of Northwestern's School
of Medicine, has successfully
treated 100 patients for a variety of "auto immune" diseases in which one's
attacks itself such as multiple sclerosis and lupus.
First, adult stem cells are taken from the patient's
blood. Then chemotherapy is used to
kill all defective immune cells. The stem cells are then injected back
into the blood stream,
which become healthy immune cells. Of 25 patients with multiple sclerosis,
all got better and "two-thirds have had no remissions," Dr. Burt reports.
He has used this same strategy to cure patients of
scleroderma (a skin disease), Crohn's Disease, which destroys the intestinal
system, Vasculitis, Wegener's Disease
(inflammation of blood vessels), Behcets, Sjogrens (involving brains and
lung), and a half dozen others.
In an August 7 radio address, John Kerry referred four
times to the "ban" on embryonic stem cell research allegedly imposed by
President Bush. That is a blatant lie.
George W. Bush is the first president to approve
federal funding for embryonic stem cell research, and $22 million of grants
have been made. Also, the National Institute of Health has made 22 "lines of
stem cells" available. Dr. Leon Kass, head of the President's
Council on Bioethics, says there are 3,500 shipments of stem cells available
Third, there is no ban on privately funded research. Christopher Reeve's foundation has made $40 million available. Harvard
is conducting its own studies. California voters will decide whether to
approve a $3 billion bond for yet more research.
Yet there are two moral questions involved. Why
shouldn't more public research money be invested in adult stem cell research
which has already been proven effective than in embryonic stem cells where the possibilities are only theoretical?
A deeper moral issue is whether it is ethical to kill
human embryos to advance research.
Advocates for doing so note that fertility clinics have 400,000 frozen
embryos which will be discarded, if they are not used for research. However
a Rand study reveals that only 11,000 of them are designated by parents for
possible research which is not enough to
treat a major disease.
Already the Biotechnology Industry Organization says it
will be "essential" to permit
widespread human cloning (called therapeutic cloning) involving thousands of
women in the
mass production of human lives that are to be exploited and destroyed to
realize the promise of embryonic stem cell research. Many studies also say
the cloned embryo has to be placed in a womb to develop it past the
embryonic stage to obtain usable cells.
This is morally abhorrent - and unnecessary.
2019: Column 1965: Protecting Girls from Suicide
Eight Reasons To Marry
Ten Myths of Marriage
The Ministry of Marriage 911
The Message by Eugene Peterson
Green New Deal
Christian Persecution Rising Abroad
Gun Control Laws Needed
The Worst Valentine:
Pornography: A Public Health Hazard
Sextortion Kills Teens
Cohabitation: A Risky Business
same sex marriage,
abortion and infanticide,