Should Celebrity Crimes Go Unpunished?
By Mike McManus
Should celebrities be allowed to commit crimes without paying a penalty?
That question lies at the center of crimes by two Hollywood celebrities and pals
of the 1970's - Academy Award-winner Director Roman Polanski and John Phillips,
Papa John, the lead singer of The Mamas & the Papas.
The facts about Polanski are not in dispute. According to testimony by Samantha
Geimer, 13, given to a Grand Jury in March, 1977, quietly unsealed four months
ago, she first posed topless for photos that the director said were for "French
Then he plied her with champagne and Quaaludes at the home of Jack
Nicholson, who was not present, and directed her to "Take off your underwear"
and enter the Jacuzzi. He photographed her nude. Polanski, then 43, took off
his clothes and entered the tub.
The girl got out, saying "I have to go home." He came inside, sat beside
her and kissed her as she pled, "No. Go away." He sodomized her and asked
Samatha if she were "on the pill." When she said, "No," he asked, "When was
your last period?" Then he had intercourse and anal sex with her. She kept
saying, "No. Stop."
However, she had so many glasses of champagne plus the Quaalude, she told
the Grand Jury, "I can barely remember anything that happened."
The sex clearly was not consensual. More important, she was only 13
years old - a minor which makes his actions a crime called "statutory rape." In
fact, the four-hour event was a classic seduction by a pedophile.
Indicted on various sex charges, Polanski agreed to a plea deal, in which
he admitted having unlawful sex with a minor that he thought would spare him
prison time beyond the 42 days he spent in jail during a court-ordered
psychiatric evaluation. However, when a Superior Court judge indicated he would
reject the plea bargain and would sentence him to prison, the director fled the
country and has lived in France for 32 years.
The director of "Rosemary's Baby" and "Chinatown," also directed a 2002
film, "The Pianist" which won an Oscar.
Los Angeles prosecutors have been ineptly trying to get Polanski
extradited to face criminal charges for years. When the LA District Attorney
heard that he was going to the Zurich Film Festival to receive an award, he
asked the U.S. Justice Department to request that Switzerland arrest him, for
possible extradition to face charges. The 76-year-old is in a Swiss jail.
However, his surprise arrest has sparked indignation in Hollywood. Film
Mogul Harvey Weinstein said, "We're calling on every film-maker we can to help
fix this terrible situation." However, he has a conflict of interest, having
bought distribution rights to the HBO documentary, "Roman Polanski: Wanted and
A petition was signed by 100 film celebrities such as Oscar winning
directors Martin Scorsese and Woody Allen, stating, "We demand the immediate
release of Roman Polanski."
Woody Allen is incensed? When he lived with Mia Farrow, he was the
"stepfather" of Korean-born Soon-Yi, who had been adopted by Farrow and Andre
Previn. Though he was 35 years older than she, he began having sex with her as
a teenager and married her in 1997.
In 1997 the victim of Polanski, Samatha Geimer emerged from anonymity to
say that she did not want the film director jailed if he returned to the United
States. "I am sure that he now understands why his actions were inappropriate
and damaging to me." However, those comments were bought with a substantial
civil settlement by Polanski.
Last week Mackenzie Phillips, daughter of Papa John Phillips, published a
memoir, "High On Arrival," which states that she and her father had an
incestuous relationship for ten years that began when she was 18 in 1979, after
her dad raped her while they were both under the influence of heavy narcotics on
the eve of her first marriage! Though she starred in "American Graffiti" at age
13 and appeared as a teen in a sitcom, "On Day At A Time," she was fired for
drug abuse, and done little since.
John Phillips is dead, and can't be prosecuted for ruining his daughter's
Roman Polanski, however, ought to be prosecuted. Why?
As Mackenzie said of her father, "My dad was not a man with boundaries."
If Polanski is imprisoned for years, fewer celebrities will have sex with
minors. Polanski says the 42 days he served "seems like a just punishment for
raping and sodomizing a 13-year-old, don't you think?" NO.
More important, stepfathers, tens of thousands of whom molested
stepdaughters - will see that they are at risk.
Criminals must be prosecuted if crime is to be reduced.
30+ Years / 1700+ Columns
2017: Column 1860: Cohabitation: A Growing Problem - Part I
Texting While Driving - A Killer
Why Have "Religious Nones" Tripled?
Norma McCorvey Roe of Roe v. Wade
The Worst Valentine: Cohabitation
Pornography: A Public Health Hazard
Christianity Gives Women Equal Opportunity
Sextortion Kills Teens
Assisted Suicide Is Growing
same sex marriage,
abortion and infanticide,