December 6, 2012
Dangers of Cohabitation
By Mike McManus
When Kansas City Chiefs linebacker
Jovan Belcher murdered his girlfriend and then committed
suicide, Bob Costas commented on Sunday Night Football, “If
Jovan Belcher didn’t possess a gun, he and Kasandra Perkins
would both be alive today.”
True, but there is a more important lesson to be learned from
this incident. Cohabitation is dangerous to both adults and
their children and should be avoided.
Dr. James Dobson interviewed me for his Family Talk radio show
on this issue recently because my wife and I wrote a book,
Living Together: Myths, Risks & Answers.
One myth believed by women is that cohabitation is a step toward
marriage. However, many men cohabit to AVOID marriage – living
together “for convenience – available sex and shared expenses,”
This can lead to conflict that becomes violent. A University of
New Hampshire study reports that “severe” violence is five times
higher for cohabitants vs. married couples.
The National Crime Victimization Survey of the Justice
Department over 9 years reported that 65% of violent crimes
against women were committed by a boyfriend or an ex-husband
with only 9% caused by a husband.
Marriage is the safest place for women – and children.
The danger actually increases when the cohabiting relationship
ends. Women are 18 times more likely to be assaulted by their
male cohabitant after breaking up than they would be by a
Cohabiting couples are as likely to have children as married
couples, but children of unwed parents are at high risk.
A recent study by the Institute for American Values, “Why
Marriage Matters,” reports that the rise of cohabitation “is the
largest unrecognized threat to the quality and stability of
children’s family lives.” A huge 42% of American children will
live in a cohabiting household and “are markedly more likely to
be physically, sexually and emotionally abused than children in
both intact, married families and single parent families.” In
fact, twice as many U.S. children will live with cohabiting
parents as those children affected by a parental divorce (23%).
While a child of divorce is 12 times more likely to be
incarcerated than one from an intact family, a kid of cohabiting
parents is 22 times more apt to be jailed.
Of the 7.6 million cohabiting couples last year, only 1.5
million married. The other 6.1 million experience what we call
“premarital divorce.” That is so painful, the number of
never-married Americans tripled from 21 million in 1970 to 63
million last year. Small wonder the marriage rate has plunged
54% in these years.
What is driving up the cohabitation rate, and reducing
marriages? States subsidize couples to live together. Subsidize
an activity, and you will get more of it.
Consider three facts. First, 41% of all births in America are to
unwed parents. That is 20 times the 2% rate of Japan, and other
Asian countries! Second, the U.S. divorce rate is also twice as
high. So only 46% of American kids are reared by married
parents. No wonder U.S. kids score only 487 on math tests vs.
540-600 by Asian kids, who are in stable homes.
Third, most unwed births are to cohabiting parents. Yet
government awards the unwed mother welfare, Medicaid, food
stamps, housing subsidies, etc. – as if she were raising the
child alone. Yet most unwed moms enjoy the salary of their
cohabiting partner as if married.
However, if the cohabiting couple does marry, they lose all
those subsidies that Heritage Foundation estimated were worth
$20,000 in 2004. Therefore, few marry.
Result: from 1990-2009, the marriage rate plunged 26% in Maine,
28% in Louisiana, 39% in Virginia, and an alarming 43% in
Kentucky in only 19 years.
There were 144,000 cohabiting couples in Virginia last year, but
only 54,000 marriages. Even though two-thirds of marrying
couples were living together, three out of four cohabitating
couples broke up short of marriage. That leaves the mother and
child on the dole till the kid turns age 18.
What can be done? It makes no fiscal sense to subsidize
cohabitation nor is it in the interest of unwed parents or their
Why doesn’t a governor make this statement in his State of the
State Address: “In Virginia we believe in marriage. Therefore,
I’d like to make an offer to cohabiting couples with children:
If you marry – which is in your best interest, and that of your
child – Virginia will not cut such benefits as Medicaid for two
years, and then taper them off over three years.”
The marriage rate would rise as cohabitation and unwed births
States should stop subsidizing cohabiting couples.
30+ Years / 1700+ Columns
2017: Column 1860: Cohabitation: A Growing Problem - Part I
Texting While Driving - A Killer
Why Have "Religious Nones" Tripled?
Norma McCorvey Roe of Roe v. Wade
The Worst Valentine: Cohabitation
Pornography: A Public Health Hazard
Christianity Gives Women Equal Opportunity
Sextortion Kills Teens
Assisted Suicide Is Growing
same sex marriage,
abortion and infanticide,