Ethics & Religion
A Column by Michael J. McManus


For Current Column
See the Home Page


About the


Search this


Column Archives
List of all columns 









For 2003 and earlier
only the title is listed.
Use the Search Function
to find the article.








About The


December 18, 2004
Column #1,216

                                           Was Mary A Virgin?
     Last week TIME and Newsweek published similar cover stories raising doubts about the virgin birth of Jesus. "Secrets of the Nativity: Why the Story of Jesus Birth Inspires So Much Scholarly Interest and Faith" was the TIME headline.

     Secrets? What secrets? Surely Scripture is clear, I thought at first. Well, not really.

     The Gospels of Mark and John do not mention the birth of Jesus. And "Matthew and Luke diverge in conspicuous ways on the details of the event," writes TIME.

     "In Matthew's Nativity, the angelic Annunciation is made to Joseph, while Luke's is to Mary. Matthew's offers wise men and a star and puts the baby Jesus in a house. Luke's prefers shepherds and a manger. Both place the Birth in Bethlehem, but they disagree totally about how it came to be there."

     As a journalist, I never saw any conflict in these accounts.  Scholars agree that Matthew was written before Luke.  Luke was a companion of Paul from his second missionary journey to his imprisonment in Rome.  I assume he read Mark and Matthew, but had his own questions about the birth of Jesus. So he interviewed Mary, a unique source of the detailed Christmas story we know best.

     Luke's Gospel begins, "Many have undertaken to draw up an account of the things fulfilled among us, just as they were handed down to us by those who from the first were eyewitnesses... Therefore, since I myself have carefully investigated everything from the beginning, it seemed good to me to write an orderly account..."

     However, TIME's account while adorned with sacred hymns ("Round yon Virgin, Mother and Child/ Holy Infant so Tender and Mild"  raises doubts about the accuracy of the story as we have known it.

      Some Jewish sources allege Mary committed adultery with a Roman soldier, Panthera, which critics say is the reason Matthew has Joseph considering divorcing her "quietly," before his dream in which an angel says "what is conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit."

     Jane Schaberg, a feminist critic at the University of Detroit, has theorized that when Mary was betrothed to Joseph, someone raped her. "The Holy Spirit, in Schaberg's version, transmutes a ritually taboo pregnancy into an occasion of glory and the birth of the Holy Child," says TIME.

     Stephen Patterson of Eden Theological Seminary "lists divinely irregular conceptions in stories about not only mythic heroes such as Perseus and Romulus and Remus but also flesh-and-blood figures like Plato, Alexander and Augustus, whose hagiographers reported he was fathered by the god Apollo while his mother slept.

     To put it plainly, such critics claim that the Gospel writers imagined the Holy Spirit and Mary engaged in the sort of physical divine-human interaction found in Greek and Roman myths.

     Raymond Brown, the deceased author of a landmark book, "The Birth of the Messiah," and a Sulpician priest, angrily retorts: "Every line of Matthew's infancy narrative echos Old Testament themes. Are we to think that he accepted all that background but then violated horrendously the stern Old Testament (rule) that God was not a male who mated with a woman?"

     Newsweek finds it odd that Jesus never referred to his virgin birth and that Mary herself "appears unaware of her son's provenance and destiny." Mark 3:21 reports that Jesus' family tried to stop Jesus' ministry, saying, "He is out of his mind." If Mary believed Gabriel, didn't she know he was not mad, but the Messiah? And wouldn't she have told his brothers?

     Good questions for which orthodox scholars I interviewed had no answers.

     Matthew explains the virgin birth as fulfilling "what the Lord said to the prophet, `The virgin will be with child and will give birth to a son, and they will call him Immanuel.'" He quotes Isaiah 7:14.

     Critics note that Hebrew word, "almah" translated as "virgin" actually refers to a "young girl, who might be a virgin or not. Prof. Eugene Merrill of Dallas Theological Seminary, retorts "The Old Testament did not have a word for 'virgin,' but when it was translated into Greek, 200 years before the birth of Christ, the Greek word for virgin, `parthenos,' was used. (The Parthenon was a temple where virgins were set apart for worship of the gods.)"

     Prof. David Scholer, of Fuller Theological Seminary, argues, "God the creator entered human history. Events like the Resurrection, which stretches what we know as human beings, and the virgin birth, we can accept as supernatural events that show the power of God."

     Newsweek reports that eight out of ten Americans agree.

  Since 1981...
2000+ Columns
  Febrary 9, 2022: Column 2113: My Farewell Column: Happy Valentine's Week
  Recent Columns
  Writing Columns About Marriage
  Will Abortion Be Made Illegal?
  Restore Voting Rights to Ex-Felons
  Progress in Black-White Relations
  Marriage Is Disappearing
  Catholic Priest Celibacy Should Be Optional
  Blacks Must Consider Marriage
  The Need to End Catholic Priest Celibacy
  More Lessons For Life
  Lessons For Life
  Rebuilding Marriage in America
  How To Reduce Drunk Driving Deaths
  The Value of Couples Praying Together
  A Case for Pro-Life
  End The Death Penalty?
  Christian Choices Matter
  The Biblical Sexual Standard
  The Addictive Nature of Pornography
  Protecting Girls from Suicide
  The Worst Valentine: Cohabitation
  Pornography: A Public Health Hazard
  Sextortion Kills Teens
  Cohabitation: A Risky Business
  Recent Searches
  gun control, euthanasia, cohabitation, sexting, sextortion, alcoholism, prayer, guns, same sex marriage, abortion, depression, islam, divorce, polygamy, religious liberty, health care, pornography, teen sex, abortion and infanticide, Roe+v+Wade, supreme court, marriage, movies, violence, celibacy, living+together, cohabitation, ethics+and+religion, pornography, adultery, divorce, saving+marriages
2022 Michael J. McManus syndicated columnist
Ethics & Religion at
Site Sponsored by