Ethics & Religion
May 16, 2019
Pope's Initiative on Sexual Abuse
By Mike McManus
Pope Francis issued a sweeping new church law aimed at holding Catholic
leadership accountable for clerical sexual abuse. It is the church's
first major step to field and investigate claims of sexual abuse.
For the first time priests and nuns will be required to report abuse
accusations to church authorities. Dioceses will have a year to set up
offices to receive complaints while offering protection for victims and
The document comes nearly three months after the pope hosted a landmark
clerical abuse summit in Rome where he pledged to deal with the
worldwide Catholic crisis. However, he offered no specifics at that
time. As one sex abuse survivor, Peter Saunders, put it: "I don't think
we can rely on the institution to clean up its act."
One organization that sent people to Rome was SNAP, the Survivors
Network of those Abused by Priests. Mary Dispenza of SNAP said, "We
wanted to hear very specific actions that would deal with clergy abuse -
and the covering up of it by bishops - but we did not hear anything like
How do the new rules measure up?
The good news is that all priests and nuns are required to swiftly
report allegations of abuse or coverup to religious authorities. They
are also encouraged (but not required) to report abuse to police if
their state requires reporting "to competent civil authorities."
However, SNAP is unimpressed. Zach Hiner, its executive director, said
the church erred by thinking it could eradicate abuse by changing the
rules but are still relying on "the very same church structures that
have been receiving and routing abuse allegations for years."
Further, the new rules also do not address the contentious issue of how
to punish clerics convicted of abuse or coverup. It's also not clear how
the church will protect whistleblowers.
Another question mark is how bishops will be policed. At present,
bishops are only answerable to the pope. The pope's new rules offer a
new way that the bishops can help police their own ranks.
If a bishop is accused of abuse or coverup, a metropolitan bishop - the
person who heads the largest regional diocese - can look into the case
with the support of Rome. If a metropolitan bishop himself is accused,
another bishop in the region is chosen to investigate.
The pope has also fired some archbishops and cardinals who have covered
up priest abuse. Former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, who ran
Washington's archdiocese, was defrocked after a church trial found him
guilty of abuse.
Late last year the Attorneys Generals of Pennsylvania and Illinois
created Grand Juries to investigate clergy sexual abuse. A Pennsylvania
Grand Jury accused 301 priests of sexually molesting at least 1,000
children. However, only two priest molesters were prosecuted. Victims of
child abuse have until age 30 to file civil suits for damages and until
age 50 to file criminal charges. Many victims are ashamed by their
experience and file no charges.
Illinois Att. Gen. Lisa Madigan reported that six Catholic dioceses,
which had previously identified 185 priests "credibly" charged with
molesting minors - identified 500 additional clergy who "received
allegations of child abuse."
The good news is that Attorneys General of 17 additional states have
launched comprehensive investigations like those in Illinois and
In California Atty. Gen. Xavier Becerrer asked Los Angeles for documents
on sexual abuse allegations over two decades. More than 100 reports of
abuse in Los Angeles, Oakland, Santa Rosa, Fresno and San Diego have
been investigated. The L.A. Archdiocese was one of the first in the
nation to publish a report in 2004 listing accused clergy.
The result? The church has paid a record $740 million in settlements to
victims - the largest in America.
The archdiocese knew for 13 years that one of its bishops, Alexander
Salazar, was accused of sexual abuse, but had not informed the public
until December - though he had been investigated by Pasadena Police back
in 2002. Fortunately, Pope Francis accepted his resignation recently.
Among the states where Attorneys General have followed the example of
Illinois and Pennsylvania are New York, West Virginia, Florida and
Kentucky. All 15 Catholic dioceses in Texas will publish a list of 286
One major reform not being discussed in any of these states - is for the
Vatican to make celibacy optional, so that married men might serve as
priests. There are 18,000 married Catholic deacons who can baptize,
witness marriages, and perform funeral services. Most would love to be
priests who can hear confessions and conduct Mass.
Their ordination, would, in time, make clergy sexual abuse largely
Copyright (c) 2018 Michael J. McManus, President of Marriage Savers and
a syndicated columnist. To read past columns, go to
Search for any topic.
2021: Column 2074: Reaching Age 80
Do Not Leave Afghanistan
Executions for Murder
A Case for Pro-Life
The Death Penalty?
Christian Choices Matter
The Biblical Sexual Standard
The Addictive Nature of Pornography
Abortion Becoming Illegal
Protecting Girls from Suicide
The Worst Valentine:
Pornography: A Public Health Hazard
Sextortion Kills Teens
Cohabitation: A Risky Business
same sex marriage,
abortion and infanticide,